The concept of Subaltern Realism is mainly associated with Mohammed Ayoob. It is a critique and modification of traditional realism to better explain the realities of the Global South.
The main book associated with Subaltern Realism by Mohammed Ayoob is:
- The Third World Security Predicament: State Making, Regional Conflict, and the International System (1995)
This book lays out his core argument about how state-building, internal insecurity, and regime survival shape the foreign policy of Third World states.
Core / Main Argument
Subaltern Realism argues that:
The primary concern of Third World (postcolonial) states is not external power politics, but internal state-building, regime survival, and domestic insecurity.
Key Points Explained
1. Security is Mainly Internal
Unlike classical realism (e.g., Hans Morgenthau):
- Focus: External threats, war, great power rivalry
Ayoob says:
- For developing countries, threats come from:
- Ethnic conflicts
- Political instability
- Weak institutions
👉 So, internal insecurity > external threats
2. State-Building is Central
- Many Third World states are recently decolonized
- Their borders and institutions are often fragile
👉 Main goal:
- Build a stable, legitimate state
3. Regime Survival Over National Power
- Leaders often prioritize staying in power
- Foreign policy is used to:
- Gain legitimacy
- Control domestic opposition
4. Different from Western Realism
Traditional realism assumes:
- Strong, stable states
- Clear national interests
Subaltern realism argues:
- These assumptions don’t fit the Global South context
5. External Environment Still Matters
- Global power structures affect these states
- But domestic weakness shapes how they respond
In One Line
Subaltern Realism says:
For Third World states, the struggle to build and maintain the state internally is more important than competing for power externally.
Importance
- Makes IR theory more inclusive of non-Western experiences
- Explains conflicts in Asia, Africa, Latin America better
- Bridges domestic politics and international relations