The idea of caste being framed as a "sacred" rather than a "secular" entity has been a significant subject in the study of Indian society and culture. This perspective is rooted in the religious and ritualistic interpretation of caste, particularly in how caste is intertwined with Hindu religious beliefs and practices.
Caste, traditionally defined in Hinduism through the varna and jati systems, is often regarded as a sacred institution because of its basis in religious texts like the Manusmriti and its association with purity, pollution, and ritual duties. In this view, caste is not merely a social hierarchy but also a divine order, where one's birth into a specific caste is seen as a result of karma, tied to notions of spiritual duty (dharma) and the cosmic order (rta). The sanctity of caste is upheld through rituals, endogamy, and strict social boundaries regarding food, occupation, and social interactions.
Sociologists like Louis Dumont argued that caste, in the Indian context, operates in the domain of the sacred, particularly because of its deep-rooted link with religious practices and ideological justifications. Dumont, in his work Homo Hierarchicus, emphasizes that caste is not just a form of social stratification but a religiously sanctioned hierarchy, where concepts of purity and pollution maintain the boundaries between different castes.
On the other hand, the "secular" understanding of caste refers to its manifestation as a social, economic, and political category, where caste functions as a tool for social stratification, control, and exclusion, often manipulated for political gain in modern times. Here, caste is seen more in terms of power, resources, and social mobility, separate from its religious connotations.
Thus, to "make caste sacred" is to emphasize its religious and ritualistic foundations, whereas to "secularize" caste would mean treating it as a sociopolitical construct.