Kohli's "crisis of governability" thesis essentially captures the inability of the Indian state to manage and mediate conflicting demands within a highly diverse and socially mobilized society. Political fragmentation, weak institutions, and economic and social inequalities interact to produce a governance crisis, which manifests as ineffective administration, policy paralysis, and weak state authority.

________________

Major Writings of Atul Kohli:

Atul Kohli is a prominent scholar in the field of political science, with a focus on comparative politics, development, and state theory. Here are some of his major publications along with their years:

1. The State and Poverty in India: The Politics of Reform (1987)
   In this influential work, Kohli explores the relationship between state interventions and poverty alleviation in India. He examines why certain states succeed in implementing reforms while others do not, with a focus on state capacity and political leadership.
2. Democracy and Discontent: India’s Growing Crisis of Governability (1990)
   This book deals with India's political challenges and the emerging crisis of governability in the late 20th century. Kohli focuses on the growing regionalism, political fragmentation, and weakening of state authority.
3. State-Directed Development: Political Power and Industrialization in the Global Periphery (2004)
   One of Kohli’s most influential works, this book compares the role of state power in industrial development in different countries, including India, South Korea, and Brazil. Kohli categorizes states into three types—cohesive-capitalist, fragmented-multiclass, and neopatrimonial—and examines their effectiveness in driving development.
4. Poverty Amid Plenty in the New India (2012)
   In this work, Kohli explores how India’s economic growth has coexisted with persistent poverty and rising inequality. He attributes this paradox to the nature of India’s political and economic institutions.
5. Imperialism and the Developing World: How Britain and the United States Shaped the Global Periphery (2020)
   This book analyzes the impact of British and American imperialism on the political and economic structures of developing countries. Kohli examines how these colonial and post-colonial influences shaped the path of development in different parts of the world.

These works collectively showcase Atul Kohli's scholarly focus on state power, economic development, political dynamics, and the socio-economic challenges in developing countries, particularly India.

Atul Kohli describes India as a "laboratory for comparative political analysis" due to its vast diversity in social structures, economic development, and political systems within a single nation-state. This phrase captures Kohli’s recognition of India’s complexities and its potential to provide insights into broader political and developmental phenomena.

The State and Poverty in India: The Politics of Reform (1987)
In this influential work, Kohli explores the relationship between state interventions and poverty alleviation in India. He examines why certain states succeed in implementing reforms while others do not, with a focus on state capacity and political leadership.

Atul Kohli's distinction between pro-market and pro-business state interventions in India during the 1980s is an important aspect of his analysis of economic reforms and state policies.

Here’s the correct explanation:

• Pro-business strategy: This approach primarily supports established producers, particularly large industrialists and business elites. It involves state policies that are designed to facilitate the interests of existing big businesses by providing them with various benefits such as subsidies, tax breaks, and relaxed regulations. The focus here is on improving the profitability and operational environment for these established players.
• Pro-market strategy: In contrast, a pro-market strategy aims at creating a competitive market environment, encouraging new entrants into the market, and benefiting consumers. It involves reducing barriers to entry, liberalizing trade, and encouraging competition, which can lead to lower prices and more choices for consumers.

In the 1980s, the Indian state moved towards more pro-business policies, with an emphasis on accommodating the demands of large and established businesses rather than creating a truly competitive market environment.

Lloyd and Susanne Rudolph described India as a "weak-strong state" to capture the paradoxical nature of India's governance system, where the state simultaneously exhibits strengths and weaknesses depending on the context.

1. Weak State: The Rudolphs argued that India can be seen as a "weak" state because it often struggles to effectively implement policies, enforce laws, and maintain authority across its vast and diverse population. Bureaucratic inefficiency, corruption, and the state's inability to penetrate rural areas or regulate powerful local elites contribute to this weakness. Furthermore, the state’s capacity is frequently compromised by political pressures from various interest groups, reflecting the characteristics of a demand polity where social forces actively shape government actions.
2. Strong State: On the other hand, India is also a "strong" state because it maintains a robust constitutional framework, democratic institutions, and the ability to centralize power in critical moments. The central government has demonstrated its strength during periods of national crisis, such as the 1975 Emergency under Indira Gandhi, when it exerted top-down control, and in its ability to hold the nation together despite immense diversity and challenges of governance. The state also plays a pivotal role in managing economic development and orchestrating social and political reforms.

The "weak-strong" state characterization captures India’s dual capacity to function both as a responsive, participatory democracy (demand polity) and a centralized authority capable of exerting significant control when necessary (command polity). This tension reflects the complexity of India's governance, where the state must balance responsiveness with authority in a diverse and often fractious society.

______________

Kohli's "crisis of governability" thesis essentially captures the inability of the Indian state to manage and mediate conflicting demands within a highly diverse and socially mobilized society. Political fragmentation, weak institutions, and economic and social inequalities interact to produce a governance crisis, which manifests as ineffective administration, policy paralysis, and weak state authority.

Kohli argues that while an alliance between the state and the business class often drives development policies, it does not inherently rule out the possibility of redistributive policies. Kohli’s analysis recognizes that even in cases where the state forms coalitions with business elites to drive growth, there can still be political pressure or strategic reasons to pursue some level of social welfare measures or redistributive policies. This can happen when there is a need to maintain social stability, manage political mobilization from disadvantaged groups, or broaden the state’s legitimacy among the populace.

In his works, particularly in State-Directed Development (2004), Kohli highlights this delicate balance between growth-oriented policies favoring the entrepreneurial class and the need for redistributive concessions to maintain political stability and social harmony.

1. The State and Poverty in India: The Politics of Reform (1987)
   In this influential work, Kohli explores the relationship between state interventions and poverty alleviation in India. He examines why certain states succeed in implementing reforms while others do not, with a focus on state capacity and political leadership.
2. Democracy and Discontent: India’s Growing Crisis of Governability (1990)
   This book deals with India's political challenges and the emerging crisis of governability in the late 20th century. Kohli focuses on the growing regionalism, political fragmentation, and weakening of state authority.
3. State-Directed Development: Political Power and Industrialization in the Global Periphery (2004)
   One of Kohli’s most influential works, this book compares the role of state power in industrial development in different countries, including India, South Korea, and Brazil. Kohli categorizes states into three types—cohesive-capitalist, fragmented-multiclass, and neopatrimonial—and examines their effectiveness in driving development.
4. Poverty Amid Plenty in the New India (2012)
   In this work, Kohli explores how India’s economic growth has coexisted with persistent poverty and rising inequality. He attributes this paradox to the nature of India’s political and economic institutions.
5. Imperialism and the Developing World: How Britain and the United States Shaped the Global Periphery (2020)
   This book analyzes the impact of British and American imperialism on the political and economic structures of developing countries. Kohli examines how these colonial and post-colonial influences shaped the path of development in different parts of the world.
6. Greed and Guns: Imperial Origins of the Developing World (1922)

1. The State and Poverty in India: The Politics of Reform (1987)
   In this influential work, Kohli explores the relationship between state interventions and poverty alleviation in India. He examines why certain states succeed in implementing reforms while others do not, with a focus on state capacity and political leadership.
2. Democracy and Discontent: India’s Growing Crisis of Governability (1990)
   This book deals with India's political challenges and the emerging crisis of governability in the late 20th century. Kohli focuses on the growing regionalism, political fragmentation, and weakening of state authority.
3. State-Directed Development: Political Power and Industrialization in the Global Periphery (2004)
   One of Kohli’s most influential works, this book compares the role of state power in industrial development in different countries, including India, South Korea, and Brazil. Kohli categorizes states into three types—cohesive-capitalist, fragmented-multiclass, and neopatrimonial—and examines their effectiveness in driving development.
4. Poverty Amid Plenty in the New India (2012)
   In this work, Kohli explores how India’s economic growth has coexisted with persistent poverty and rising inequality. He attributes this paradox to the nature of India’s political and economic institutions.
5. Imperialism and the Developing World: How Britain and the United States Shaped the Global Periphery (2020)
   This book analyzes the impact of British and American imperialism on the political and economic structures of developing countries. Kohli examines how these colonial and post-colonial influences shaped the path of development in different parts of the world.
6. Greed and Guns: Imperial Origins of the Developing World (1922)

Books by Sudipta Kaviraj:

1. The Unhappy Consciousness: Bankim Chndra Chattopadhyay and the Formation of Nationalist Discourse in India (1995)
2. "The Imaginary Institution of India: Politics and Ideas" (2010)
3. "The Trajectories of the Indian State: Politics and Ideas" (2012)
4. The Invention of Private Life: Literature and Ideas (2014)
5. "Civil Society: History and Possibilities" (Edited with Sunil Khilnani, 2001)
6. "The Enchantment of Democracy and India" (2011)
7. "Modernity and Politics in India" (2018)

Edited Volumes:

1. "Politics in India" (2012)

_________________

The Burden of Democracy (2003) was written by Pratap Bhanu Mehta 

The central conclusion of The Success of India’s Democracy of Atul Kohli is that India’s democratic stability is not accidental but the result of a complex interplay of historical legacies, institutional design, political inclusiveness, and effective leadership. Despite persistent inequalities, periodic challenges, and ongoing conflicts, India’s democratic framework has proven adaptable and resilient. This resilience can be largely attributed to the inclusive political strategies that allowed for the representation of multiple interests and the ability of the state to adapt to changing social and political dynamics.

In summary, the book makes a case for the success of India’s democracy by focusing on how institutions, leadership, social inclusion, and the adaptability of democratic practices have enabled the country to sustain democracy against the odds.

The central conclusion of The Success of India’s Democracy of Atul Kohli is that India’s democratic stability is not accidental but the result of a complex interplay of historical legacies, institutional design, political inclusiveness, and effective leadership. Despite persistent inequalities, periodic challenges, and ongoing conflicts, India’s democratic framework has proven adaptable and resilient. This resilience can be largely attributed to the inclusive political strategies that allowed for the representation of multiple interests and the ability of the state to adapt to changing social and political dynamics.

In summary, the book makes a case for the success of India’s democracy by focusing on how institutions, leadership, social inclusion, and the adaptability of democratic practices have enabled the country to sustain democracy against the odds.

The central conclusion of The Success of India’s Democracy of Atul Kohli is that India’s democratic stability is not accidental but the result of a complex interplay of historical legacies, institutional design, political inclusiveness, and effective leadership. Despite persistent inequalities, periodic challenges, and ongoing conflicts, India’s democratic framework has proven adaptable and resilient. This resilience can be largely attributed to the inclusive political strategies that allowed for the representation of multiple interests and the ability of the state to adapt to changing social and political dynamics.

In summary, the book makes a case for the success of India’s democracy by focusing on how institutions, leadership, social inclusion, and the adaptability of democratic practices have enabled the country to sustain democracy against the odds.

Sanskritization is a sociological concept introduced by Indian sociologist M.N. Srinivas. It refers to the process by which lower or middle caste groups in India seek upward social mobility by adopting the customs, rituals, and practices of higher castes, particularly the Brahmins. This includes changes in diet, dress, language, and religious practices. By aligning themselves with the cultural traits of higher castes, these groups aim to elevate their social status within the hierarchical caste system. Sanskritization is a form of social mobility, but it doesn't necessarily result in structural changes to the caste system itself.

______________