India is Pursuing a Positive Asymmetry in South Asia
What is Positive Asymmetry?
Positive asymmetry refers to a foreign policy approach in which a larger and more powerful state voluntarily offers greater concessions, cooperation, and benefits to its smaller neighbours without expecting immediate reciprocity.
Since India is the largest country in South Asia in terms of population, economy, military capability, and geography, it has often pursued positive asymmetry to build trust and promote regional stability.
This concept is closely associated with the Gujral Doctrine.
How is India Pursuing Positive Asymmetry?
1. Gujral Doctrine (1996–98)
- Formulated by Prime Minister I. K. Gujral.
- India declared that it would not insist on reciprocity from its smaller neighbours:
- Bangladesh
- Nepal
- Bhutan
- Maldives
- Sri Lanka
Example
- India offered economic and diplomatic concessions without demanding equivalent returns.
2. Development Assistance
India provides:
- Lines of Credit
- Grants
- Infrastructure development
- Capacity-building programmes
- Educational scholarships
to neighbouring countries.
Examples
- Bhutan – Hydropower projects.
- Nepal – Roads, railways, and integrated check posts.
- Maldives – Greater Malé Connectivity Project.
- Sri Lanka – Housing and railway rehabilitation projects.
3. Humanitarian Assistance and Disaster Relief (HADR)
India is often the first responder during crises.
Examples:
- 2004 Indian Ocean Tsunami
- 2015 Nepal Earthquake (Operation Maitri)
- COVID-19 Vaccine Maitri initiative
- Assistance to Sri Lanka during its 2022 economic crisis
4. Trade Concessions
India grants:
- Preferential market access
- Duty concessions
- Reduced trade barriers
to neighbouring countries.
5. Connectivity Projects
India promotes regional integration through:
- BBIN Initiative
- India-Bangladesh railway connectivity
- Inland waterways
- Cross-border electricity trade
- Digital connectivity
6. Security Cooperation
India assists neighbours through:
- Military training
- Counter-terrorism cooperation
- Maritime security
- Coastal surveillance
- Intelligence sharing
7. Regional Initiatives
India promotes:
- Neighbourhood First Policy
- SAGAR (Security and Growth for All in the Region)
- MAHASAGAR (Mutual and Holistic Advancement for Security and Growth Across Regions)
- BIMSTEC cooperation
- Indian Ocean cooperation
Examples of Positive Asymmetry
| Country |
India's Positive Asymmetry |
| Bhutan |
Hydropower investments and development assistance |
| Nepal |
Earthquake relief, infrastructure, trade facilitation |
| Bangladesh |
Land Boundary Agreement (2015), Lines of Credit, connectivity projects |
| Sri Lanka |
Economic assistance, housing, crisis support |
| Maldives |
Infrastructure projects and security cooperation |
Why Does India Follow Positive Asymmetry?
- Promote regional stability.
- Build trust with neighbouring countries.
- Reduce the influence of external powers.
- Enhance regional connectivity.
- Strengthen India's leadership role in South Asia.
- Ensure a peaceful neighbourhood for economic growth.
Criticism
- Some critics argue that neighbours do not always reciprocate India's goodwill.
- Concerns exist that China's growing economic presence through the Belt and Road Initiative (BRI) has reduced the effectiveness of India's asymmetric approach in some countries.
- Domestic political considerations in neighbouring states sometimes limit the impact of India's initiatives.
___________________
India is Strategically Contained by the China–Pakistan Partnership
Meaning of Strategic Containment
Strategic containment refers to a situation in which a country's strategic options, security, and regional influence are constrained by the coordinated actions of other states.
In the South Asian context, many strategic analysts argue that the China–Pakistan strategic partnership poses a significant challenge to India's security by creating pressure on both its western and northern borders.
How Does the China–Pakistan Partnership Strategically Contain India?
1. Two-Front Security Challenge
- India shares disputed borders with both China and Pakistan.
- Any simultaneous military pressure from both countries could compel India to divide its military resources.
Examples
- 2020 India–China tensions in Eastern Ladakh.
- Continuing India–Pakistan tensions along the Line of Control (LoC).
2. China–Pakistan Economic Corridor (CPEC)
- CPEC is a flagship project of China's Belt and Road Initiative (BRI).
- It connects China's Xinjiang region to Gwadar Port in Pakistan.
- Parts of CPEC pass through Gilgit-Baltistan, a region claimed by India as part of the former princely state of Jammu and Kashmir.
India's Concern
- India opposes CPEC because it passes through territory claimed by India.
- It may strengthen China's long-term economic and strategic presence in Pakistan.
3. Gwadar Port
- China has invested heavily in Gwadar Port on Pakistan's Arabian Sea coast.
- Gwadar enhances China's access to the Indian Ocean and supports its maritime strategy.
Strategic Significance
- It provides China with an alternative route for energy imports.
- It increases China's strategic footprint near India's western maritime approaches.
4. Military Cooperation
China is one of Pakistan's principal defence partners.
Cooperation includes:
- Fighter aircraft (e.g., JF-17 programme)
- Naval vessels and submarines
- Missile technology
- Air defence systems
- Joint military exercises
This cooperation enhances Pakistan's military capabilities.
5. Nuclear and Missile Cooperation
China has played an important role in Pakistan's civilian nuclear energy programme and has been associated with technological cooperation that strengthened Pakistan's strategic capabilities.
This has contributed to maintaining a strategic balance with India.
6. Diplomatic Support
China has frequently supported Pakistan on international issues.
Examples:
- Discussions on Kashmir at international forums.
- Delays in listing certain Pakistan-based militants at the UN in earlier years (though positions have evolved over time).
7. String of Pearls Strategy
Some analysts argue that China's development of ports around the Indian Ocean—including Gwadar (Pakistan), Hambantota (Sri Lanka), and Kyaukpyu (Myanmar)—could increase its strategic influence in the region.
India views this as a potential challenge to its maritime security.
8. Indian Ocean Presence
China has expanded:
- Naval deployments,
- Anti-piracy missions,
- Port access arrangements, and
- Maritime infrastructure investments.
This has increased Chinese activity in the Indian Ocean Region (IOR), where India has traditionally had significant influence.
India's Response
India has responded through:
- Neighbourhood First Policy
- Act East Policy
- SAGAR (Security and Growth for All in the Region)
- MAHASAGAR (Mutual and Holistic Advancement for Security and Growth Across Regions)
- Strengthening ties with:
- the United States,
- Japan,
- Australia (through the Quad),
- France,
- ASEAN countries.
- Development of Chabahar Port in Iran as an alternative connectivity route to Afghanistan and Central Asia.
Critical Perspective
While the China–Pakistan partnership undoubtedly creates strategic challenges for India, describing India as "strategically contained" is debated.
Many scholars argue that:
- India retains considerable strategic autonomy.
- India has expanded defence partnerships and maritime capabilities.
- India's economic growth and diplomacy provide significant countervailing influence.
- Regional dynamics are shaped by multiple actors rather than a simple containment strategy.
Thus, "strategic containment" is an analytical perspective rather than an uncontested fact.